‘Love & Basketball’ Could Not Be the Excellent Love Story, however It is Nonetheless a Love Story

Within the ever-popular dialogue about what much-loved motion pictures did not age effectively, Love & Basketball is incessantly within the combine.

Although Gina Prince-Bythewood wrote the movie as a love story, through the years, the connection dynamics between Quincy (performed by Omar Epps) and Monica (performed by Sanaa Lathan) have come below nearer scrutiny, with many coming to the conclusion that their love story was a poisonous one.

And whereas I agree, I nonetheless assume two issues may be true on the similar time: It’s attainable that, even when what they shared wasn’t exemplary of a wholesome relationship, there was actual love on the core. It wasn’t best, but it surely was there.

To start with, neither of them got here from dad and mom who might mannequin constructive relationships themselves. For Monica, who was headstrong, impartial and pushed, she noticed her mom quit her goals of being a caterer in trade to remain house as a substitute, and turn out to be somebody who was basically at her husband’s beck and name.

That meant that when it got here to pursuing her profession objectives, Monica was uncompromising; and when it got here to figuring out a number of the unhealthy patterns in her relationship with Q, she might not have had the know-how. And if she had a inkling, who might she ask for assist?

Then there’s Quincy. His father was a big-shot NBA participant who needed Junior to observe in his footsteps. And although I really assume he was an honest father — usually pushing for Q to complete his faculty training earlier than going professional — he was, objectively, a horrible husband. He ran the family with an iron fist and belied his stand-up man facade by repeatedly being untrue, even fathering a toddler exterior of his marriage.

With examples like these, Quincy and Monica by no means stood an opportunity. Q particularly had zero emotional intelligence. His means of claiming “I really like you” was “Of all these women, you’re the one I do know who’s for actual.” It was tragic.

Let’s additionally not overlook that these two have been childhood sweethearts and one another’s first crush. Within the scene the place they’re 11 years outdated and Q asks Monica to be his girlfriend, they negotiate the phrases of their relationship as if it’s a enterprise deal. Fairly than the everyday harmless, pure pre-adolescent relationship, what we see with Q and Monica on this scene is the start of a repetitive, harmful sample, and certain sufficient, the scene ends with the 2 engaged in literal fisticuffs. 

However amid all of the chaos between the 2 of them, there’s one thing undeniably romantic there.

One in every of my favourite scenes comes when Quincy’s dad and mom’ relationship begins to crumble and we see that Monica was not simply his love, however a secure house for him. He knocks on her window as his dad and mom are having what should be their millionth argument and with out saying a phrase, she lets him in, offers him some blankets, passes a pillow and lets him sleep on her bed room ground. 

I actually want there have been extra moments the place we noticed him do the identical for her, however that scene confirmed the intrinsic understanding the 2 had. They knew and understood issues about one another that different individuals merely didn’t. 

The cringiest scene for many individuals — myself included — is when she asks to play him for his coronary heart, simply two weeks earlier than his marriage ceremony. However once more, I believe it’s so off-putting now as a result of we take a look at it via our present lens versus the context by which it was made.

After I first watched the film within the early aughts, it was one of the vital emotional moments within the movie and if we’re being sincere, it was badass. So usually in romantic dramas, it was the lads who have been making these sweeping gestures, however in Love & Basketball, it was the girl — and that, as soon as once more, spoke to her company. Positive, Q wasn’t Prince Charming, however he is who she needed and he or she went after him. 

I believe the factor I hate most about how individuals view Love & Basketball now’s the way it’s framed as if it’s the first instance of a foul love story. My Finest Pal’s Wedding ceremony, Learn how to Lose a Man in 10 Days, and The Wedding ceremony Planner are fairly alarming in hindsight as effectively, and but, individuals someway are ready to talk about them with nostalgic affection.

By no means miss a narrative — join PEOPLE’s free every day publication to remain up-to-date on the very best of what PEOPLE has to supply​​, from movie star information to driving human curiosity tales.

Again in 2000, we did not have psychology phrases akin to gaslighting, poisonous masculinity, fawning and bread crumbing, now so prevalent within the zeitgeist. There was nonetheless a stigma in direction of individuals who sought remedy, so how we watched and analyzed movies was utterly totally different. And positively, a lot of the best way we checked out love was additionally very totally different.

I might by no means in my proper thoughts defend Love & Basketball because the gold normal of how relationships must be, romantic or in any other case. I’m particularly not keen on how Monica’s ardour for basketball is vilified and he or she was deemed “temperamental” for being so devoted to her dream.

Nonetheless, the rationale the movie grew to become an on the spot traditional, and why it’s held a particular place in our hearts for therefore lengthy, is as a result of it resonated ultimately. Whether or not it was from pining for unrequited love, recognizing our personal poisonous patterns or just making us need higher for ourselves, Love & Basketball was revolutionary.  

It’s not the proper love story … however what romance is ideal?